Karl Rover, Karl Rover, send Mehlman right over...
Ok, so pretty much everyone admits that Karl Rove is the man who outed CIA agent Valerie Plame. Now what? Will there be a swift apology by Bush and the firing or resignation of Rove? Does Iraq have uranium?
Enter RNC Chairman Ken Mehlman...
Mehlman released a statement today calling the attacks on Karl Rove "partisan", and proceeded to present "facts" to back up the statement that Rove didn't mean to out Valerie Plame, but was just trying to "discourage a reporter (Cooper) from writing a false story based on a false premise..."
One problem with Mehlman's "facts" is that they are lies.
Along with the "facts" in Mehlman's statement are some real facts (truths):
- "Fact": Cooper's own email claims Rove warned of potential inaccuracies in Wilson's information
Truth: The fact that Rove warned Cooper about inaccuracies doesn't mean that there were any.
- "Fact": Wilson falsely claimed that it was VP Cheney who sent him to Niger...
Truth: In his Op-Ed, "What I Didn't Find In Africa" Wilson says that officials at the CIA claimed Cheney's office had "questions about a particular intelligence report" and agency officials wanted Wilson to "travel to Niger to check out the story so they could provide a response to the vice president's office". At no point in the article does Wilson claim to have been PERSONALLY asked by Cheney to report to him.
- "Fact": Wilson denied his wife suggested he travel to Niger, but documentation showed she proposed his name.
Truth: Yes, she may have proposed his name, but she did not have the authority nor ability to personally send him since she was not in charge of the case. A fair interpretation would be that though she may have suggested his name, those in power knew that he was well trusted by the first president Bush and by the PM of Niger. Why not use someone who already has the contacts and know-how to get to the relevant information?
- "Fact": Wilson's report on Niger had "thin" evidence and did not change conclusions of Analysts and other reports.
Truth: Rove was the "government official" calling Wilson's work "thin" and shoddy. Need I say more? No, but I will anyway: Wilson's statement didn't change any conclusions because they were in agreement with him. George Tenet himself stated in a July 11, 2003 press release that the famous "16 words should never have been included in the text written for the president". Why not? Because they were not true, they were "facts". This gives credibility to Wilson's statement that there was no reason to believe that Iraq was trying to purchase uranium from Niger. No shoddy work here Rove, just facts with (no quotation marks).
- "Fact": Sens. Roberts, Bond and Hatch all dismissed Wilson's Claims.
Truth: Who asked them? Who cares what they think? Anyone? Anyone? Bueller? Bueller?
- "Fact": Wilson tied to the 2004 Kerry Campaign for President
Truth: Wilson donated $1,000 each to Al Gore and George W. Bush Jr. for the 2000 presidential campaign. Wilson worked for Bush's daddy. Partisan? Nah. At least not until...May and Sept. of 2003 when Wilson donated a total of $2,000 to Kerry's campaign coffers, but this was after an unnamed source (Rove) had tried to discredit him and his wife's cover as a CIA agent was blown. Wilson was a career diplomat with friends on both sides of the isle until the Bush White House tried to destroy him. I can't say I blame him for fighting back any way he could. Besides, this has no bearing on the either the "facts" or the facts. Wilson's work on the Iraq/Niger connection was well before his work with the Kerry campaign.
Basically, Mehlman's press release is just another attempt to smear Wilson's name and to point the finger away from the White House, Bush and Rove. Guess what? It ain't workin'.
In Wilson's own words: http://www.alternet.org/stories/19271
In Mehlman's own words: http://www.rnc.org/News/Read.aspx?ID=5620
